Scientific DiscoveryUMCES EducationIntegration and Application


Research on the Risks and Benefits of Nonnative Oysters

The Maryland Department of Natural Resources (DNR) and the Virginia Marine Resources Commission are working with the Army Corps of Engineers on an Environmental Impact Statement to study and review options for oyster restoration, including introducing a nonnative species, Crassostrea ariakensis, also known as the Suminoe oyster. The DNR's perspective is that populations of the native Eastern oyster, Crassostrea virginica, are so depressed and limited by diseases that immediate consideration is warranted for the introduction of reproducing populations of Suminoe oysters, which have been shown to grow well in the Chesapeake Bay and survive the diseases that afflict the Eastern oyster.  There is considerable controversy over the prudence of introducing a nonnative, potentially invasive species and about the time required to complete research and risk assessments to support such a decision.

Two scientific bodies have considered the introduction of the Suminoe oyster and made recommendations concerning the risks and benefits that should be addressed and the research required to accomplish this:  

  • A National Research Council committee examined three management options, including both prohibition of the introduction of nonnative oysters and proceeding with the introduction of reproductive diploid oysters.  It recommended the middle-road option of continuing the trials of open-water aquaculture of sterile, triploid oysters while engaging in a parallel program of strategic research over six to seven years that would support a risk assessment of the potential introduction of reproductively capable diploid Suminoe oysters in the Bay. (click here for the NRC Report) 

  • The Scientific and Technical Advisory Committee of the Chesapeake Bay Program identified and prioritized research requirements, focusing on high and essential priority research that could be completed in a five-year program. (click here for the STAC Report)

The University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science is actively engaged in research on the risks and benefits of Suminoe oysters in the Chesapeake Bay supported by Maryland Sea Grant, Maryland DNR, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.  The UMCES approach is cautious, involving rigorous testing of hypotheses concerning risks and benefits and a high level of biosecurity to prevent the inadvertent release of Suminoe oysters capable of reproducing or diseases that may be borne by the nonnative oysters into the wild.  UMCES President Donald Boesch has presented testimony to the Maryland General Assembly on the questions being addressed, research being conducted and the likely timeframe for a scientifically rigorous assessment. 

Recently Completed and Ongoing Research

Project title (Sponsor) UMCES Principal Investigators
Characterizing the performance of Suminoe oyster in Maryland (Sea Grant) Kennedy Paynter, CBL
Potential for natural predators to control the spread of the Suminoe oyster (Sea Grant)

Roger Newell, HPL

Victor Kennedy, HPL

Modeling the dispersal of Suminoe oyster larvae in Chesapeake Bay (Maryland DNR) Elizabeth North, HPL
Behavioral responses of Suminoe and Eastern oyster larvae (Maryland DNR) Roger Newell, HPL
Evaluation of gametogenesis and spawining cues for Suminoe oysters (Maryland DNR) Donald Meritt, HPL
Behavioral and substrate selection of Suminoe oyster larvae (Maryland DNR) Mario Tamburri, CBL
Competitive interactions between Eastern and Suminoe oysters and reef development (Maryland DNR) Roger Newell, HPL
Investigation of Suminoe oyster reefs in Laizhou Bay, China (Maryland DNR) Kennedy Paynter, CBL
Long-term mesocosm studies of competitive interactions between Suminoe and Eastern oysters (NOAA) Roger Newell, HPL
Behavior, substrate selection and survival of Suminoe oyster larvae in response to variations in environmental conditions (NOAA) Mario Tamburri, CBL
Response of different strains of Suminoe oyster larvae to environmental change (NOAA) Roger Newell, HPL
Predation by polyhaline invertebrates on young Suminoe oysters (NOAA) Victor Kennedy, HPL
DirectionsContactSerach
University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science
P.O. Box 775, Cambridge, MD 21613 410.228.9250
Last modified March 1, 2005
For questions or problems with this site, contact webmaster@ca.umces.edu